ANSWERS TO REVIEW QUESTIONS
prepared by Rabbi Eliezer Chrysler
Kollel Iyun Hadaf, Jerusalem
Previous dafEruvin 21
ERUVIN 21, 22, 23, & 25 sponsored by a generous grant from an anonymous donor. Kollel Iyun Hadaf is indebted to him for his encouragement and support and prays that Hashem will repay him in kind.
(a) Even a person may draw water well in the Pasei Bira'os and
drink it there - if the well is wide, making it difficult for a person to
clamber down it.
(b) Seeing as the Beraisa forbids filling a bucket of water well of
Pasei Bira'os and placing it in front of one's animal, what does our
Mishnah mean, asks Rav Anan, when it permits doing so, provided the head and
most of the animal is inside. (See Tosfos, who explains that either Rav Anan
understands that 'Lo Yemalei' of the Beraisa includes when he is holding
both the bucket and the animal, or he holds that, when the owner is holding
the bucket and the animal, 'Roshah ve'Rubah' is not necessary - otherwise,
in either case, the Kashya would be easily answerable.)
(c) The Gemara answers - that the Beraisa is not speaking by a regular case
of Pasei Bira'os, but one which leads, not to the street (as in most cases)
but to a feeding-trough stands at the entrance of the area of the Pasei
Bira'os (part of it actually inside the entrance), and the animal is
standing in a house immediately behind the trough (as it already explained
on the previous Amud - though for different reasons).
(a) Burganin - are small temporary guards' huts, which increase the outside
extremity of the town - provided they are within seventy Amos of the last
(b) 'Burganin' did not apply in Bavel - because Bavel was full of pools of
water, which rendered them useless.
(c) 'Pasei Bira'os' did not apply in Chutz la'Aretz (which did not include
Bavel) - because people did not tend to travel from one town to the other
(as they did in Bavel) - therefore there was no D'var Mitzvah (like the Olei
Regalim) to permit Pasei Bira'os - and we learnt above that Chazal only
permitted Pasei Bira'os for the benefit of the Olei Regalim (including
similar type Mitzvos).
(d) 'Aval Ipcha Avdinan' - means that 'Burganin' did apply in Chutz
la'Aretz, and 'Pasei Bira'os' in Bavel.
(a) According to the second Lashon ...
The Seventy and two thirds' Amos of 'Burganin' - is rooted in the Beis
Sasayim of the Mishkan, which was seventy and two third Amos squared (as we
learnt at the beginning of the Masechta).
1. ... 'Burganin' did not apply in Chutz la'Aretz either - because there
were many thieves, who would steal the actual huts, thus rendering them
(b) The distance between Barnash and the Shul in Daniel - was three Parsah
2. ... 'Pasei Bira'os' did not apply in Bavel - because there was an
abundance of water - and Chazal permitted Pasei Bira'os only because of the
water shortage of the Olei Bavel (when they arrived in Eretz Yisrael for
(c) It was permitted to walk from one to the other on Shabbos - because of
all the ruins of old buildings that still remained between them, which
included many walls. These have the Din of a house, and are considered an
extension to the town, even though they are no longer inhabited.
(a) David ha'Melech, Iyov and Yechezkel failed to explain - the extent of
(b) 'Kinim' referred to by Yechezkel is an expression of punishment, and
'Hegeh' one of joy.
(c) If Torah is a folded scroll of twenty Amos by ten, written on the back
as well as on the front - then when opened out and peeled (to add the back
to the front). it will be eighty Amos by ten. And if the world is described
as being a Zeres (half an Amah), then we have to reckon Torah as being a
hundred and sixty by twenty (i.e. three thousand, two hundred) times the
size of the world.
(a) The two copper pots referred to by Mari bar Mar, one containing high-
quality figs, the other, rotten ones - symbolized the Tzadikim and the
(b) He learns Pasuk "ha'Duda'im Nasnu Re'ach" - that even the
Resha'im will give a good smell (in the World to Come).
(c) "ve'Al Pesachenu Kol Megadim", according to Rava - refers to the young
Jewish women, who 'close their wombs' ( Lashon of 'Agad' - to tie),
opening them for their husbands only; Alternatively, they tell (
Lashon of Magid - to tell) their husbands when they see blood and are
forbidden to them.
(d) "Chadashim Gam Yeshanim Dodi Tzafanti Lach" - pertains to the new
decrees which Yisrael formulated - and kept, over and above those which
Hashem decreed on them.
(a) Rava explains the Pasuk "ve'Yoser Meheimah Be'ni, Hizaher Asos Sefarim
Harbeh" - as a warning to Yisrael to observe the Mitzvos de'Rabbanan more
even than the Mitzvos mi'd'Oraysa, because whereas the former include many
ordinary Mitzvos Asei or Lo Sa'aseh, for contravening any of the Mitzvos
de'Rabbanan one is Chayav Misah.
(b) We learn Pasuk "u'Poretz Geder Yishchenu Nachash" - that
someone who breaches the fence which the Rabbanan made around the Torah
(i.e. he contravenes the Mitzvos de'Rabbanan), is Chayav Misah.
(c) The Torah did not include the Mitzvos de'Rabbanan in the Mitzvos - it
did however, invite the Chachamim to initiate their own Mitzvos, even going
so far as to warn us about their severity, as we just explained.
(a) The Gemara initially explains the Pasuk "ve'Lahag Harbeh Yegi'as Basar"
- to mean that someone who mocks the words of the Chachamim - is sentenced
to be burnt in boiling excrement (see Gitin, 57a, where the Gemara relates
that, in spite of the Gemara's objection here, that is the punishment which
Yeshu receives in the World to Come).
(b) The Gemara rejects this explanation, because then Shlomoh should not
have written "La'hag", but "La'ag". "La'hag" means not 'to mock', but 'to
(c) The Gemara finally explain this Pasuk - to mean that each time that one
involves himself (speaks) in Divrei Torah (however many times one learns
some Torah topic or other), he finds it tasty (like the taste of meat).
(a) On that particular day - the prison guard, on the excuse that 'so much
water' would only give Rebbi Akiva the strength to dig his way out to
freedom, poured out half his meager ration.
(b) Rebbi Akiva argued - that, seeing as someone who transgresses an Isur
de'Rabbanan is Chayav Misah, it would be better for him to die naturally of
thirst, rather than to die because he had contravened a Mitzvah de'Rabbanan.
(c) Rebbi Yehoshua ha'Garsi served him in prison. He was called 'ha'Garsi'
either after his town, or because he was by profession, a bean-grinder.
(d) When Rebbi Akiva's colleagues heard of his Mesiras Nefesh for the
Mitzvah of Netilas Yadayim - they said in admiration that, if he displayed
such supreme Mesiras Nefesh in his old age (he was already one hundred and
twenty years' old) when he was so weak, imagine what he must have been like
in his younger years.
(a) Shlomoh ha'Melech instituted - Netilas Yadayim (before eating) and
(b) Hashem reacted by saying "Be'ni, Im Chacham Libcha, Yismach Libi Gam
(a) When Yisrael asked Hashem to go out with them into the fields - they
were in fact, asking Him not to judge them like city-dwellers, who were
constantly guilty of theft, adultery, and false and vain oaths, but like
farmers, who studied Torah in poverty.
(b) When Yisrael said to Hashem "Nalinah ba'Kefarim, Nashkimah ba'Keramim" -
they were telling Hashem that they would show Him 'ha'Kofrim' i.e. people
whom Hashem had showered with goodness, but who had subsequently denied His
Omnipotence; But they would also show Him the 'Keramim' i.e. the Batei
Kenesi'os and the Batei Medrash, where He would see ...
1. "Parchah ha'Gefen" - refers to people who learn Tenach;
2. Pasach ha'Semadar" - to people who learn Mishnah;
3. "Henetzu ha'Rimonim" - to people who learn Gemara. They are the glory of
Yisrael and their greatness.
(a) We learn from ...
1. ... "Vayedaber Sheloshes Alafim Mashal" - that Shlomoh ha'Melech gave
three thousand parables on every topic of Torah;
(b) And Pasuk in Koheles "Od Limed Da'as es ha'Am" - that he fixed
signs and comparisons by which to remember both the written and the oral
2. ... "Vayehi Shiro Chamishah va'Alef" - that he gave a thousand and five
parables on every de'Rabbanan;
(c) Shlomoh ha'Melech also instituted 'Sheni'os la'Arayos (certain cases of
(d) When Chazal say that, until Shlomoh ha'Melech, Torah was like a basket
without handles - they mean, that until Shlomoh initiated the above
Rabbinical decrees, Torah was not safe-guarded, just like a basket that does
not have handles with which to hold it, is not safe.
(a) Rav Chisda, quoting Mar Ukva, learns Pasuk in Shir ha'Shirim
1. ... "Kevutzosav Taltalim" - that it is possible to Darshan on every
single crown (of the Sha'atnez Gatz letters) heaps and heaps of Halachos.
(b) Ravah explains 'be'Mi she'Mashchir Panav ke'Orev' - to refer to someone
who is hard on his children (because he knows that Hashem will look after
them) like a raven (who forsakes its young, leaving Hashem to come and feed
it - which He does, by providng them with worms - according to the Medrash,
by creating worms ir own dung).
2. ... "Shechoros ke'Orev" - that Torah is to be found by those who go early
on the morning ("Shechoros" = Shachris) to the Beis-ha'Medrash and stay
there until late at night ("ke'Orev" = Ma'ariv).