REVIEW QUESTIONS ON GEMARA AND RASHI
prepared by Rabbi Eliezer Chrysler
Kollel Iyun Hadaf, Jerusalem
Previous daf Nedarim 71
NEDARIM 71 - has been dedicated to the memory of Kodesh ben Simcha Gedaliah,
who completed his mission on this world in but a few weeks.
(a) If a betrothed girl who is divorced, becomes betrothed again, who annuls
the Nedarim that she declared whilst she was betrothed to the first Arus?
(b) Who annuls them if she became a Bogeres before becoming betrothed the
second time, or if the man who divorced her was her husband (and not just an
(a) What does Shmuel learn from the Pasuk "ve'Im Hayo Sihyeh le'Ish
(b) Who asked the Kashya 'Minalan', which prompted Shmuel's answer?
(c) If our Mishnah was speaking in a case when the first Arus was not aware
of the Arusah's Nedarim, why would the Tana then need to stress that she was
divorced on the same day?
(d) What makes us so certain that Shmuel is not merely finding the source
for the Din mentioned by the Tana of our Mishnah?
(a) We suggest that the Pasuk "(u'Nedarehah *Alehah*") might be confined to
Nedarim about which the first Arus had been unaware. Those Nedarim that he
knew about however, can only be annulled by her father ('Nisroknah').
is an alternative explanation?
(b) How does Shmuel in fact know to include even Nedarim of which the first
Arus was aware, from "Alehah"?
(c) We learned a Beraisa in support of Shmuel. The case in the Reisha is
exactly the same as that of Shmuel.
What does the Tana Kama of the Beraisa
say in the Seifa, where the first Arus heard about the Arusah's Neder,
annulled it and then died?
(d) Why does the father need to annul the Arus' part again, seeing as the
Arus already annulled it?
(a) What does Rebbi Nasan comment on the previous Beraisa?
The Seifa of the Beraisa refers to when 'Ba'alah' heard the Neder and
annulled it before dying.
(b) Some commentaries say that Beis Hillel only disagrees with the Din in
the Seifa, but that he agrees with that of the Reisha (Shmuel's Din).
is the problem with that?
(c) How do we resolve this problem (by drawing a distinction between the
earlier case (where there was only one Arus) and our case (where there are
(d) Tosfos however, disagree with those commentaries. According to them,
Beis Hillel argue in the Reisha too.
What do they hold in the Reisha,
where Beis Shamai permit the father to annul his daughter's Nedarim in
conjunction with the second Arus?
Who is meant by 'Ba'alah'?
Answers to questions
(a) Beis Shamai holds that even Nedarim about which the Arus knew,
'Nisroknah Reshus le'Av'.
Why is the Neder not weakened by the fact that
the Arus annulled them?
(b) We learned earlier that when the father annulled his daughter's Neder
and died, the Arus, who only heard about the Neder after the father's death,
cannot annul it ('Lo Nisroknah').
Why does this seemingly clash with Beis
Shamai's opinion here?
(c) How do we resolve this problem? What is the difference between the Arus
being left with the father's portion to annul, and vice-versa?
(d) What is Beis Hillel's reasoning? What is the basis of their Machlokes?
(a) Why was it necessary to stress according to Beis Shamai, that even those
Nedarim that the Arus knew about are annulled by the father, seeing as we
already established earlier that everyone agrees with that?
(b) And why do we say that *even* those Nedarim that the Arus knew about are
annulled by the father ... ', as if Nedarim that the Arus did not know about
are certainly annulled by the father, when in reality, they are not?
(c) In any event, we see from Beis Hillel that both the father and the
second Arus must nullify even those Nedarim about which the first Arus was
Is this proof confined to Beis Hillel, or can we also prove it from
Beis Shamai, who rules here that the father annuls the Nedarim on his own?
(a) The B'nei Yeshivah asked whether, if the Arus divorced the Arusah, it
has a Din of Shesikah (silence) or of Hakamah (upholding the Neder).
Answers to questions
are the ramifications of the She'eilah?
(b) On what basis might it have the Din of Hakamah, seeing as he did not say
(c) How do we know that the word 'Ba'alah' in this context means Arus and
(d) Why does they say ...
- ... 'va'Ahadrah *be'Yomei'*?
- ... 'va'Ahadrah ... '? Would it make any difference if a second Arus
- would betroth her?