POINT BY POINT SUMMARY
by Rabbi Ephraim Becker
Kollel Iyun Hadaf, Yerushalayim
Rosh Kollel: Rabbi Mordecai Kornfeld
Ask A Question on the daf
Previous dafPesachim 102
1) SHINUI MAKOM (cont'd)
(a) Answer: This Bereisa is the lone opinion of R. Yehudah (and may
not be used to question R. Chisda) as we see in the Bereisa.
2) MITZVOS CHAVILOS CHAVILOS
1. A group who leaves [Akru Ragleihem] need not say Berachos.
(b) Question: But this Bereisa should be a question on R. Yochanan?!
2. [R. Yehudah] This is only if they leave someone behind.
1. The Akru Ragleihem refers to those foods which would require
a Berachah in their place, inferring that even Rabanan would
require them to say Berachos for other foods!
(c) Answer: This Halachah is not to say Berachos even for other
foods, and the words Akru Ragleihem are used for R. Yehudah.
2. Question: But wasn't this already asked once?
3. Answer: Let this be yet another question.
1. Even for foods which require a Berachah in their place,
(d) A Bereisa was taught in support of R. Chisda.
2. R. Yehudah requires that they have left someone behind.
(a) [R. Yehudah] If Shabbos begins while a group is eating its meal,
a cup is brought and Kidush is recited (and then Birkas HaMazon
is recited on a separate cup).
(b) [R. Yosi] They need not interrupt, but when the finish their meal
they recite Birkas HaMazon over the first cup, and Kidush over
(c) Question: Say both on one cup?
(d) Answer: We do not recite the two sanctifications on one cup (on
account of Mitzvos Chavilos).
(e) Question: But we see from the Bereisa that we *may* bundle
Berachos onto one cup when he does not have enough wine!?
(f) Answer: A case of insufficient wine is different.
(g) Question: But Rav taught that we say YKN"H on YomTov after
Shabbos (bundling Kidush with Havdalah, even, presumably, on
Pesach when everyone has sufficient wine)!?
(h) Answer: If Rav meant Pesach, he would have included Shehechiyanu
(YKNH"Z) [thus he could still be speaking of a lack of wine].
(i) Question: But even on the first night of Pesach we bundle the
Berachos, there is only a dispute regarding the order?!
(j) Answer: Kidush and Havdalah may be combined while Havdalah and
Birkas HaMazon are separate.