|(Permission is granted to redistribute this material as long as the Kollel
header and the subscription info at the end are included.)
GRAPHICS FOR LEARNING THE DAILY DAF
brought to you by Kollel Iyun Hadaf of Har Nof
Rosh Kollel: Rabbi Mordecai Kornfeld
Email - firstname.lastname@example.org
Shabbos Graphic #2b
Shabbos Daf 85a
(1) See Insights for a summary of the various opinions of the Rishonim
concerning the distance of ground from which a plant draws nourishment, and
whether "Rosh Tor" applies in an Arugah.
(2) This is a way of filling the entire field with Arugos, one next to the
other (according to RASHI), or one at the corner of the other (according to
the other Rishonim).
(3) According to RASHI, Shmuel is not concerned that one might fill up the
entire sides of each Arugah (including the corners).
(4) (a) According to TOSFOS (and also, apparently, according to the RAMBAM
and VILNA GA'ON), Shmuel utilizes "Rosh Tor" to permit planting Arugos in
close proximity to each other, but he requires that the leaves from the
plants of each Arugah be bent into their appropriate Arugah (this is what
the Gemara means when it says "b'Noteh Shurah l'Kan v'Shurah l'Kan").
(b) The pattern of the seeds in each of the Arugos is identical to the
pattern described earlier, in row #3 of the graphic.
(5) The pattern of each Arugah, according to every one of the Rishonim
except for Rashi, is identical to the pattern depicted earlier, in row #1
of the graphic.
(6) According to the RASH, it suffices to distance each Arugah from the
other by 1 1/2 Tefachim. Since the border between Arugos is one Tefach wide
(and not two Tefachim, like Rashi and Tosfos maintain), Shmuel permits
planting in adjacent Arugos by planting the seeds in the Arugah half a
Tefach away from the border, in one of every two adjacent Arugos. In this
manner one is able to fill his entire field with Arugos, and there is no
fear that he will plant them too close together if he fills up the sides.
(7) The VILNA GA'ON in Shenos Eliyahu maintains that whenever an Arugah is
completely filled with one type of seed (covering the entire 6-by-6 area of
the Arugah), it is permitted to plant other types of seeds around the
*outside* of the outer rim of the 6x6 Arugah (leaving the *corners
fallow*). The reason is because a fully-planted Arugah is, in itself,
distinct from all the surrounding rows of seeds (because a 6-by-6 plot
stands out by itself from the rest of what is sown).
For questions or sponsorship information, write to email@example.com